A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Only variable references should be returned by reference

Filename: core/Common.php

Line Number: 257

Shaped By Us - Home
Navigation menu icon

Remember me for 2 weeks
If you are on a public or shared computer we recommend you do not use this feature.

Login



to top

For the lead

Rate ideas

Rating ideas is pretty self explanatory, team members can vote on their favourite ideas using the five star rating system. When the voting has ended the challenge moves on to ‘refining the idea' where the ideas are re-ordered based on the scores, displaying the top three as gold, silver and bronze.


Setting the Idea Criteria:


We have created a simple list of three things to consider when team members are scoring the ideas:

  • Does this idea solve the challenge?
  • Is it achievable / practical?
  • Is the idea sustainable?
  • Does it benefit the community?

As the challenge Leader you can change and adapt the scoring criteria if you need team members to focus on particular needs, or feel a few extra consideration would help people to consider what is best. For example if your challenge is about an activity for young people you might want to encourage people to consider the fun factor of an idea, or that about how engaging it will be for young people.

Here is a quick list of things to think about when considering an idea:

  • Does it solve the challenge?
  • Is it achievable?
  • Is it sustainable?
  • Is it inclusive?
  • Is it scalable?
  • Is there commercial opportunity?
  • What are the benefits?
  • What are the barriers to making this happen?
  • How might you overcome these?

This is quite a long list, we would advise trying to keep the list to five or less. Don’t forget your team can also use this guide to inform their decisions. 


Completing voting


As leader it is up to you to close the voting and move on to the next stage ‘refine idea’. 

This action is quite straight forward; simply click the ‘mark as complete’ button in the ‘idea checklist’ box. This will calculate the votes and order the ideas best to worst displaying the top three ideas. Of course we would suggest getting as many people to rate the ideas as possible and give your team as much time as possible to go through and vote for their favourite idea. If you are not getting a large amount of interest or votes, don’t just move on regardless; make use of social media to share the challenge and ideas so you can get a wider range of views before moving on.



For the team

Rate ideas

On each challenge page there an ‘ideas checklist’. This is a checklist of things to consider when rating the ideas submitted by the team. 


Scoring out of five

If you are having a bit of trouble deciding how to score ideas, here is a simple overview of what we free each rating means:


No stars: This idea has no merit what so ever. 

One star: Bad idea – This idea barely solves the challenge, is hugely impractical, impossible to implement or is completely unsustainable.

Two stars: Poor idea – This is idea has some major flaws, it may solve the challenge but isn’t particularly practical, has little consideration for sustainability or scalability.

Three stars: This idea has potential; it does solve the challenge but might not have all the answers for being sustainable. It might not be hugely realistic. 

Four stars: This idea is really good, it solves the challenge and considers how it could be a sustainable and inclusive solution. 

Five stars: This idea ticks all the boxes; it solves the challenge, it is achievable and benefits the community. This is a real game changer. 


If you would like more help to decide how to score the various ideas try considering the following:


  • Does it solve the challenge?
  • Is it achievable?
  • Is it sustainable?
  • Is it inclusive?
  • Is it scalable?
  • Is there commercial opportunity?
  • What are the benefits?
  • What are the barriers to making this happen?
  • How might you overcome these?


Happy rating!



Newsletter

Sign up to receive our newsletter.